Case note: 'BCG' and Attorney-General's Department (Freedom of information)
29 October 2026
'BCG' and Attorney-General's Department (Freedom of information) [2026] AICmr 98 (9 October 2026)
This recent decision of Justin Lodge, Acting General Manager Freedom of Information Case Management, delegate of the Information Commissioner, (the Delegate) discusses the application of s 24A of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (the FOI Act).
In this matter, the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) affirmed the Attorney-General’s Department’s (the Department) decision to refuse the Applicant’s request for certain documents, on the grounds that all reasonable steps had been taken to find the documents and that the documents could not be found or did not exist.
This case provides a useful reminder of what sort of evidence an agency may consider providing in Information Commissioner review (IC review) proceedings regarding a decision under s 24A of the FOI Act, to refuse access to a document on the grounds that all reasonable steps had been taken to locate documents within the scope of the request and that the requested documents cannot be found or do not exist.
Background
On 6 August 2024, the Applicant made an FOI request to the Department, seeking certain documents relating to Australian citizen participation in a foreign military.
The time period of the request was from 1 January 2022 to 6 August 2024.
On 19 December 2024, after the statutory timeframe for making a decision had expired (such that the request was deemed to have been refused), the Department made a purported decision to refuse access to the requested documents under s 24A of the FOI Act, as it was satisfied that the documents sought could not be found or did not exist.
On 28 January 2025, the Applicant sought IC review.
The issue to be decided in this IC review was whether the Department had taken all reasonable step to identify documents within the scope of the request before finding that the documents could not be found or did not exist.
Section 24A – Request may be refused if documents cannot be found or do not exist
Section 24A of the FOI Act requires agencies to take ’all reasonable steps’ to find a requested document prior to finding that the document cannot be found or does not exist.
The Department’s submissions
The Department submitted that all reasonable searches within relevant branches had been undertaken. In particular, it submitted that the relevant Department branches (being the Security Law and Policy Branch (the SLPB) and the Office of International Law (the OIL) had undertaken comprehensive searches for documents within the scope of the Applicant’s request.
While the searches conducted by the branches had identified a large number of documents containing key terms from the Applicant’s request, upon further examination, the Department was satisfied that the documents located did not actually fall within the scope of the Applicant’s request.
Following the commencement of the IC review, the Department undertook additional searches using further relevant search terms. Similarly, no documents within scope of the Applicant’s request were located.
The Applicant’s submissions
The Applicant submitted that, the searches undertaken by the Department were inconsistent with the 'reasonable steps' requirement set out in s 24A of the FOI Act because:
- the Department initially sought to refuse the request on the ground of a ’substantial and unreasonable diversion of resources’, having identified over 1,000 potential documents
- 'it is improbable that the Security Law and Policy Branch and the Office of International Law did not identify any relevant documents’ noting that legal advice on foreign excursions is a responsibility of the Department branches that undertook the searches, and
- the Department ’has taken a narrow interpretation of the scope and excluded documents relevant to the subject matter of the request’.
Consideration
The Delegate noted that the Department had provided fulsome details of all the searches undertaken, including:
- the dates on which searches were undertaken
- the business areas that undertook the searches
- the locations searched (and reasons why irrelevant locations were not searched)
- the search terms used, and
- the outcomes of the searches undertaken.
The Delegate referred to the matter of Barot and Secretary, Department of Home Affairs (Freedom of Information) [2025] ARTA 1798 (16 September 2025) (Barot), where the Tribunal ’emphasised the importance of accurately scoping the request in determining whether the test under s 24A has been met’.
The Delegate considered the Applicant’s request and the evidence of the Department’s searches to date and was satisfied that the Department had correctly interpreted the scope of the request for the purpose of conducting its searches.
Further, the Delegate accepted that the Department had taken all reasonable steps to locate documents within the scope of the Applicant’s request, because the Department had explained where the relevant material would be held (the PDMS or Content Manager), had undertaken multiple searches of relevant locations using appropriately broad terms , and had explained why the material identified did not in fact fall within the scope of the Applicant’s request.
The Delegate therefore found that the Department had taken all reasonable steps to locate documents relevant to the Applicant’s access request. Accordingly, the Delegate was therefore satisfied that the documents could not be found or did not exist
Key takeaways
- Agencies should ensure that they have accurately interpreted a request when seeking to rely upon s 24A of the FOI Act. If a request has been inaccurately interpreted or scoped, it may be difficult to establish that all reasonable steps have been taken to locate documents within the scope of an Applicant’s request.
- As in this case, Agencies should make sure that there is fulsome evidence of all searches made, including the locations searched and keywords used.
If your agency requires advice or assistance with the processing of FOI requests, or managing IC review matters, please reach out to Chantal Tipene and our team of leading FOI specialists would be happy to assist.
